Skip to main content

Are left-wing people (liberals) more compassionate than right-wing people (conservatives)?

Quite a few differences in personality, typical behaviour and beliefs have been identified between people with left-wing and those with right-wing political views. Many have been highlighted in the recent book The Republican Brain which, despite the title and bias of the author, highlights strengths and weaknesses of those from both ends of the political spectrum and also suggests our society needs people from both ends of the political spectrum (or at least people with the personality traits that are typical from each end).

One difference that was not mentioned but which I'd like to propose is that left-leaning people have a stronger innate sense of compassion than right-leaning people. This could be viewed as an attack on conservatives but I’m more of the view that no amount of susceptibility to feeling compassion is right or wrong – people simply differ. Left-leaning people will view right-leaning people as lacking in compassion at times while those of the right often view those of the left as having too much compassion (the term ’bleeding heart’ is sometimes used in this context).

Consider some of the points of difference often associated with the left-right divide and how greater feelings of compassion in left-wing people could help explain these:
  • Left-wing people advocate more government welfare for the poor than right-wing people because they literally care more about people in need.
  • Right-wing people are more likely to approve of the death penalty because they feel less compassion for people who have committed crimes such as murder.
  • Left-wing people are more likely to approve of increased rights for gays because they care more about the happiness of other people.
  • Right-wing people are more likely to support military action because they feel less compassion for people hurt by war.
  • Left-leaning people tend to favour increased immigration to help those from poor or war-torn countries because they'd like to help these people more
The frequency and strength of feelings of compassion certainly do not explain all of the differences between left and right-leaning people but it may help explain many quite well.

It is, however, important to note that most right-leaning people do care about other people. It's simply that other priorities (or instincts) might influence their decisions and views more in comparison to compassion than in left-leaning people.

Popular posts from this blog

How do we explain human behaviour?

Why do we do what we do from moment to moment and can it be explained? For most of my life I have tried to understand why people behave the way they do and why different people behave differently given the same apparent options. I suspect all people, at least subconsciously, try to understand human behaviour to better get along in life, but it has perhaps been more explicit in my thinking for a long time. I’d like to record here and in subsequent posts my thoughts on this and anything related to help focus the development of my ideas. I also hope that other people will read these ideas over time and potentially contribute their own thoughts by way of comment. To start I’d like to propose the idea (hypothesis) that underlying the motivation for all our behaviour are many simple instincts or drives (I will use a broad definition for the word 'instinct' that includes 'drives'). If, as I will assume, this is the case then what are they and can distinct instincts be i...

The drive or instinct to increase the respect other people have for us

I would firstly like to expand on how I believe instincts work to influence our behaviour. Initially, we feel an urge or drive to behave or think in a certain way. For example, to say something we think is funny that might make another person laugh. If successful, we then feel good, at least partly because that person’s respect for us might have improved slightly. Thus, satisfying the instinct provides the reward of feeling good or at least feeling that we did something good (for us). My belief at the moment is that this need to increase respect is one of the strongest in most people. It competes with other instincts at all times however and, while not always prevailing, often seems to win. For example, this might explain why soldiers perform acts of bravery despite great risk to their life (and thus going against their survival instinct). I suspect it is to increase the respect they receive from not only their fellow soldiers but also everyone else, including their en...